U.S. President-elect Donald Trump has pledged to initiate “the largest deportation effort in American history,” regardless of the associated costs. However, experts warn that the economic impact of such a campaign could be more significant than he anticipates.
Trump won the recent presidential election on a platform that emphasized strict immigration policies, including plans for mass deportations targeting between 15 million and 20 million undocumented immigrants. Vice President-elect J.D. Vance has stated that the administration would initially focus on deporting 1 million undocumented individuals, starting with those deemed “the most violent criminals.”
As Trump prepares to take office in January, his deportation plans face numerous challenges, including logistical, legal, political, and financial hurdles. Economists predict that if implemented on a large scale, these deportations could negatively affect the U.S. economy by increasing inflation and hindering economic growth.
Adam Posen, president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics, remarked, “Leaving aside the human issues and legal concerns, this could be very destructive economically.” He emphasized that many people may not fully grasp the potential scale of this impact.
According to estimates from the Department of Homeland Security, around 11 million people are living in the U.S. without legal status. This group represents nearly 5 percent of the total workforce and plays a crucial role in sectors like agriculture, construction, and hospitality. Data from 2017 indicated that about 66 percent of undocumented immigrants had resided in the U.S. for over a decade, with approximately 4.4 million U.S.-born children living with undocumented parents.
Removing such a significant portion of the labor force could have widespread repercussions for the economy. Michael Clemens, an economist at George Mason University, warned that mass deportations would lead to fewer job opportunities for U.S. workers and increased budget deficits, resulting in a higher tax burden on Americans.
While specific details of Trump’s deportation strategy remain unclear, he has confirmed intentions to declare a national emergency and involve military resources in the effort. Tom Homan, designated as the next “border czar,” stated that plans are already underway to enhance enforcement capabilities.
The financial implications of this mass deportation initiative are substantial. Estimates from the American Immigration Council suggest that deporting 1 million immigrants annually could cost around $88 billion each year. In total, removing all 13.3 million undocumented individuals or those with temporary protections could reach nearly $968 billion over ten years.
Andrea Velasquez, an economist at the University of Colorado Denver, noted that deportations are costly and would impose a significant fiscal burden on the government.
Undocumented immigrants contribute significantly to the economy as workers and consumers. They represent about 40 percent of the agricultural labor force and paid approximately $96.7 billion in taxes in 2022. Despite their contributions, state and local governments often bear higher costs for services like healthcare and education.
Proponents of mass deportation argue it could benefit American workers by creating job opportunities and addressing housing shortages. Vance claimed that removing undocumented immigrants would compel employers to offer higher wages to attract U.S.-born workers.
However, past experiences with mass deportations suggest that such policies may harm employment outcomes for American workers instead. A study examining the impacts of the Obama administration’s Secure Communities program found that mass deportations led to lower employment rates and wages for U.S.-born workers.
The Peterson Institute for International Economics conducted analyses indicating that if Trump were to deport 1.3 million undocumented immigrants, both GDP and employment would decline significantly by 2028. In a more extreme scenario involving 8.3 million deportations, GDP could drop by as much as 7.4 percent.
Overall, experts warn that Trump’s mass deportation plans could lead to increased inflation and economic instability across various sectors, particularly agriculture.
In summary, while Trump remains committed to his deportation agenda, economic experts caution that the costs associated with such an initiative may ultimately outweigh any perceived benefits for American workers or society as a whole.
Related topics:
- U.S. Universities Sound Alarm for Foreign Students Amid Trump’s Immigration Crackdown
- Trump’s Bold Threat: Massive Tariffs on Mexico, Canada, and China to Combat Immigration and Drug Trafficking
- Is Illegal Immigration the Real Culprit Behind Italy’s Surge in Sexual Violence?
